Beethoven was so famous that even centuries later people know him by just his last name. You can have no interest in any kind of music whatsoever, and you’ve still probably heard Symphony No. 9 in half a dozen movies. Yes, his music was so popular he just had to number his symphonies and people knew what they were. So it would be very cool if it turned out one of the world’s most famous composers, perhaps THE most famous composer, were actually Black, right? Yeah, I’d find that very interesting.
And it’s not a new idea. People have been circulating the theory that Beethoven is Black off and on for years, mainly based on descriptions of his appearance as “dark” and “swarthy,” and descriptions of his facial features that might be interpreted as descriptions of a Black man’s face.
It’s popping up again now, Know Your Meme reports, because Twitter started sharing a post on a defunct website called the Concordian about Beethoven’s heritage.
BEETHOVEN WAS BLACK?? The plot thickens pic.twitter.com/qQMRiJhfI1
— shan 🪐 (@sshandinx) June 18, 2020
The theory is that his parents came from areas of the country that were at some point under Moorish rule. The Moors were a dark-skinned group of Muslim people who came from North Africa and took over parts of Spain. It’s impossible to say whether or not his parents were directly related to any Moorish people, and by the time Beethoven was born, the Moors hadn’t been the dominant group in their birthplaces for over 300 years. Describing a white person as “swarthy” was also a relatively common thing to do if they were remotely dark in skin tone or hair. Basically, the information is inconclusive and will remain so.
That hasn’t stopped people from running with it, and while many are delighted just to celebrate or joke about Beethoven being Black, a few historians and musicologists are taking this trending opportunity to talk about actual Black composers of Beethoven’s era and ask an important question: why don’t we know more about them?
Don’t know how credible the research on Beethoven’s heritage is, but there are certainly black composers of his time worth checking out: Le Chevalier de Saint-Georges, Francis Johnson, George Bridgetower. pic.twitter.com/M09mmIrH3X
— Tracy Q. Loxley (@TracyQLoxley) June 18, 2020
Francis Johnson (blue coat) was the first African-American to have his own sheet music published, and was a respected virtuoso on the violin and bugle.
— Tracy Q. Loxley (@TracyQLoxley) June 18, 2020
George Bridgetower was born in Poland and spent most of his life in England. He was such a respected violin virtuoso that Beethoven originally wrote his Violin Sonata No. 9 for him to perform.
— Tracy Q. Loxley (@TracyQLoxley) June 18, 2020
There are already many Black European composers whose music deserves our ears. Chevalier de St. George. Samuel Coleridge Taylor. Edmond Dédé. Amanda Aldridge. Instead of programming Beethoven’s 5th another time, why aren’t musicians performing their works? pic.twitter.com/t2jrME6M40
— Dr. Kira Thurman (@kira_thurman) June 18, 2020
And that’s a good question. Much more interesting than trying to argue Beethoven was white, if any really wound up racists were planning on spending their day doing that.
Beethoven wasn’t even black but the number of racists this is gonna anger, I say we keep the agenda going. They’ve whitewashed enough of our history, it’s payback time. William the Conqueror was from Nigeria.
— TJ 🇱🇨🇯🇲 (@Quantum_King_) June 18, 2020
Twitter remains undefeated.
1.
Beethoven was black? pic.twitter.com/EG5HoV1uqr
— A Girl Has No Name (@_cherieldn) June 18, 2020
2.
Y’all: Beethoven was Black!
Me: pic.twitter.com/W31fz8mlTa
— Σlimothy 🎓 (@_DJSlimB) June 18, 2020
3.
Beethoven was black?? I knew his shit cranked for some reason pic.twitter.com/hHm3i4pHvq
— Muse. 🧘🏾♀️ (@moniquerleee) June 18, 2020
4.
yoooooo beethoven is black???? LES GOOO (i made the beat)
— 🖤🤍 BM 💫💿 (@blaccmass) June 18, 2020
5.
Beethoven was deaf and still had rhythm. That was a black man.
— Deepak Okra (@EasyStreetKeys) June 18, 2020
6.
I had to listen for myself it all makes sense Beethoven was tuff ! pic.twitter.com/9O2urkzqUz
— Jussmikey⚡️ (@jussmikeyy) June 18, 2020
7.
I found out Beethoven was black today pic.twitter.com/i1Wjmac6sf
— CMDEUX (@king_savage002) June 18, 2020
8.
When you find out why Beethoven is trending. ✊🏾😂pic.twitter.com/RtMr9Yammp
— DataDave (@DataDaveTV) June 18, 2020
9.
Beethoven at home vs Beethoven at his concerts pic.twitter.com/tp1JeGW0cC
— Josiah Johnson (@KingJosiah54) June 18, 2020
10.
beethoven being black was not the plot twist i expected this year pic.twitter.com/tMV5KFMuXj
— stream astronomy club on netflix (@TotallyMelody) June 18, 2020