Pixabay

People Are Sharing The Creepiest Thing Said To Them On A First Date (20 Stories)

Have you ever gone on a first date with someone, and they said something so outrageous or disturbing that it made you want to bolt immediately?

Dating is not for the weak, and some people are flat-out strange and even scary.

On Reddit, people are sharing the creepiest thing someone said to them on a first date, and a lot of these stories could be the set-up for a horror movie.


A girl who tries on a wedding dress? Some vampire requests? Repeated assertions by men that it would be really easy to rape their date? Cannibalism? Be careful out there! 

1.

“Friend told me the guy not only asked for a selfie but posted on facebook with the caption, ‘my queen.’ First time meeting.” — Dubstepface

2. 

“I told this guy I played the piano, and like half an hour later he said: ‘If I wanted you to always remember me, I’d break your ring fingers. You know, cause they don’t heal well and then you’d always think of me when playing.’ Suffice to say, I left the restaurant fairly quickly.” — NotGreatAtSocializin

3. 

“Mid date he placed his hand on my stomach and said, ‘My son will grow here.'”— irememberthepotatoho

4. 

“‘Can I cut you and drink it?’ She was serious.” — fujfuj

5. 

“She was driving us back home from the restaurant and started saying things like, ‘ya know, you’re in my car now I technically can take you wherever I want.. you’re like my prisoner.'” — Baby_Driver_2007

6. 

“‘I just really like mustard’ as she continues suck mustard packets worst part, we were at a somewhat nice restaurant. SHE BROUGHT MUSTARD TO EAT.” — baconkiller1

7. 

“‘I invited my ex to join us for lunch.'” — Excellent-Raccoon-32

8. 

“‘I love Asian girls, they remind me of children.'” — hedgiebetts

9. 

“Went out with a girl one night and after dinner she drove me up into the mountains (I was new to the area) and after a while, when there were no more lights, she started talking about serial killers. I still remember her saying, ‘I used to think about getting away with stuff like that sometimes.'” — zDemon1c

10. 

“Called their mom in front of me to say they met a real winner and how they were done with their ex. Not sure if this counts but it was really uncomfortable.” — cryptoscopophilia

Patricia Grisafi

Patricia Grisafi, PhD, is a freelance writer and educator. Her work has appeared in Salon, Vice, Bitch, Bustle, Broadly, The Establishment, and elsewhere. She is passionate about pit bull rescue, cursed objects, and designer sunglasses.